Tuesdays With Dorie: Rugelach
I was really looking forward to this week’s Tuesdays With Dorie because I really enjoy rugelach. I made my very first batch of it during TWD 1.0, and they turned out to be a lot of fun to make.
These, however…
This week’s hosts were Margaret of The Urban Hiker, and Jessica of My Baking Heart.
It started out innocently enough. The dough was as easy as could be to make, though I was a little concerned about how much butter and cream cheese needed to be used! I could only imagine it would be worth it, though.
I refrigerated the dough overnight and was really excited to get the whole thing going the next afternoon. I can never seem to get perfectly shaped rectangles or even circles when I’m working with dough, but I coaxed it the best I could.
I couldn’t find apricot lekvar at the store so I got apricot preserves instead — so yummy.
I used one cup of raisins and one cup of chopped dried cherries. I almost wish I’d just stuck to raisins because I felt there was a lot of waste once things got going, and those cherries were delicious.
For the life of me I could not get these things to roll properly. They were long enough but the amount of filling was a bit too much, I think. They just would not seal. Even after they sat in the fridge for most of the afternoon and evening, I couldn’t get them closed any more than what you see in the picture.
Which, like I mentioned, made for a lot of waste when it came time to cut them. I was really disappointed with how much of the filling was pulled right out of the roll (even with the sawing motion of a serrated knife, as instructed), and since the logs are brushed in an egg wash, I didn’t feel comfortable picking at the fruit.
More waste. This bowl was where I put the rolls after they were cut. It’s a sugar, brown sugar, cinnamon and chopped walnut mix that sticks to the outside of each roll. There was a TON left over (at least a cup and a half) and I couldn’t do anything with it but toss it, because of the raw egg wash (as you can see, even more fruit fell out).
I also didn’t get anywhere near 48 rolls. Maybe 24?
Then, to add insult to injury, this is what I pulled out of the oven.
A literal hot mess.
Each roll just kind of collapsed and gave up (much like how I was feeling at this point). They really were that flat.
Knowing that not everything can be a stunner, Mike and I each grabbed a fork and gave it a try right off the parchment paper.
And it was absolutely delicious.
So, as frustrating as the last half was, and as much as they did not look like they were supposed to:
~ The house smelled absolutely amazing. Like, everyone-bugging-me-for-half-an-hour amazing.
~ They really are delicious.
~ We reheated them this morning for breakfast and nearly wiped out the whole batch.
I’m glad I gave it a try, and though I don’t think I’ll ever attempt them again, the family is sure happy I did this time!
Oh, no, a hot mess! But they were super tasty and I’m glad they didn’t go to waste.
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 3:51 am
I’m really glad they tasted so good — that on top of all the work and the visual failure may have driven me to drink 😉
[Reply]
Your first photo is gorgeous…nice lighting too.
Yes, these are fussy to make, but delish!
~Carmen
http://bakingismyzen.wordpress.com
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 3:52 am
Thank you, Carmen! The deliciousness definitely made up for the lack of visual appeal!
[Reply]
I am glad that they tasted good .. loved these cookies too …. it is messy but it is so worth it …. your cookies looks good … !!!
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 5:41 pm
Thanks, Saira! Thankfully the taste made the effort worth it!
[Reply]
That stinks! At least you did all enjoy them. I had quite a bit of the sugar mix left over, too. With all of those toasted nuts, I didn’t want to toss it. I put it in the freezer to use in some cinnamon rolls in the future. Keep smiling and baking!
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 5:41 pm
Ooooh why didn’t I think of that! What an excellent idea!
[Reply]
So funny, I used the exact phrase “hot mess” in my post too! I really thought that first picture looked delicious when I got here. I wondered what you were talking about when you said they didn’t turn out! Glad they tasted great even though they were frustrating.
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 5:43 pm
I had hard time picking the best looking of the bunch for the picture 😀 The taste definitely made up for the process!
[Reply]
Wow, sorry they were a mess but glad they were tasty!
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 5:44 pm
Yeah, thankfully the taste made up for the frustration!
[Reply]
Awww!!! I had the exact same troubles as you, almost step by step!!! *virtual hug* I think mine held together (barely) by sheer force of will and a lot of squishing… my counters were a horror show after I was done with everything. But at least you enjoyed them after all that 😉
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 5:44 pm
It’s comforting to know I wasn’t alone! I think if they hadn’t tasted as good as they did, my kitchen would not be standing today 😀
[Reply]
These definitely look perfect to eat from the tray!
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 5:45 pm
Hi Gretchen! Yeah, once they came out looking like that I wasn’t going to bother with dirtying up anything else!
[Reply]
I think your rugelach and my rugelach were in cahoots with each other. Or they just couldn’t take the heat! haha
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 5:46 pm
Exactly! I take a little bit of comfort knowing I wasn’t alone in my frustration, but at least they tasted good!
[Reply]
I think there were quite a few of us who had trouble with this one! I love the picture anyway. 🙂 The taste is the thing!
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 5:58 pm
Thanks, Rebecca! The taste definitely made up for the trouble!
[Reply]
Ha! I also got a hot mess when I pulled the pan out of the oven! So bad, that one of my pans had to be thrown out.
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 5:59 pm
Oh no! I worried that mine had spread out onto the pan because I can’t fit it into my sink or my dishwasher. I’m sorry you had to toss yours 🙁
[Reply]
I’m glad you found the positive side! They were, indeed, delicious!!
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 6:00 pm
The taste definitely made up for how they looked!
[Reply]
Mine did not look so hot either. I definitely cherry-picked for the photos. At least they were delicious and I have to say you are definitely more cautious than me because I ate every damn sour cherry that fell out of my logs regardless of the egg wash. Good thing I didn’t get sick!
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 6:02 pm
I so considered it – I love dried cherries! I’ve got a little one having some tummy issues though so we’ve been super cautious all weekend 😀
[Reply]
I’m so sorry they didn’t turn out well. Mine weren’t very pretty either.
perhaps the apricot jam just got too runny in the oven to hold together. The lekvar didn’t liquefy in the heat the way a jam would. could that have been part of the problem?
at any rate….I’m glad they tasted good anyway!
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 6:03 pm
Ooh, I think that’s a definite possibility! The lekvar photos do look like they held together a lot better.
[Reply]
After looking at a lot of folks’ photos, I have to say, I do have an appreciation of the imperfect, spilling-out versions (like in your first photo … ditto for my own efforts). They seem somehow more inviting to dig in and scarf up. 🙂
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 6:05 pm
Exactly, and I have to agree – it definitely made it easier to dig right into it straight from the pan! 😀
[Reply]
Your rolls with fruit filling falling out and dough not meeting looked just like mine. Since I had only spread lekvar and cinnamon mixture on the other half at that point I just kept rolling and used that other half to close the roll. My rolls were bigger but they cut just fine after chilling and did well when baked. I went ahead and did the same with the other half. No way could all that filling form a pinwheel with 5″ of dough. They were delicious.
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 6:06 pm
I really wish I’d done that as well – I wouldn’t have minded having bigger pinwheels if it had meant they’d just stayed together in the oven!
[Reply]
Yours turned out just like mine. Very messy. They were wonderful but worth the cost and time… meh….. Keep the dough recipe around, that seems to be the best part!
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 6:10 pm
Yeah, I agree. The taste made it worth the effort *this* time, but I can’t imagine giving them another shot!
[Reply]
These did taste good, though I too was frustrated that there was so much waste involved. I don’t like to have to throw out perfectly good food.
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 8:00 pm
I agree completely. Some have mentioned using it later for cinnamon rolls or other treats — I really wish I’d thought of doing that!
[Reply]
Enjoyed your post. This was a new recipe for me and I loved making it. http://www.praycookblog.com
See you on the 20th!
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 8:05 pm
Hi Catherine! Thank you!
[Reply]
These were really tasty, weren’t they? I would suggest chilling them in the freezer for at least 10 minutes before putting them in the oven. This dough was so buttery and rich I knew they’d melt in the oven, so I froze the tray of rugelach, then brushed with eggwash and sprinkled demerara sugar right before baking. Happy Tuesday!
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 10:04 pm
That is an excellent suggestion! I chilled them as the book instructed, but I think they would have really benefited from one more stay in the fridge. Thank you, Yuri!
[Reply]
What a bummer about the hot mess! After reading about your experience with TWD 1.0 I’m now going to try the Rugelach in Dorie’s Baking book. It looks gorgeous in your photo!
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 10:05 pm
Thank you, Janet! I would definitely do the rugelach from the first round again!
[Reply]
my first try looked just like yours – I was so upset. Thankfully I had a few good ones, but even the “mess” tasted good:)
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 10:08 pm
Hi Heather! I agree, they really did taste just as good as the pretty ones!
[Reply]
Dear Heather, Thanks for stopping by my blog — this has me in hysterics laughing! I didn’t read my directions correctly and didn’t know until this very moment that I was suppose to brush the egg over the entire roll AND THEN cut into pieces! I wondered why my Rugelach has so much more cinnamon/sugar on it than others! Now we know, and I prefer it my way 🙂 Nice to meet you and I look forward to baking with you again! Blessings.
[Reply]
Heather
March 6th, 2012 at 11:53 pm
Oh! I totally thought you did it on purpose and thought it was a great idea! 😀 It totally makes sense to me, since I wanted the topping to stick to the cut sides too and ended up just kind of pressing it into it. If I were to make these again I’d definitely do it your way!
[Reply]
Wow, that’s rough. Although, I had to laugh at the thought of eating them off the pan with a fork. Totally sounds like something I would do (have done…)
I stayed away from most of the fruits & nuts in the filling. My track record with stuff like that isn’t the best 🙂
Cute post
[Reply]
Heather
March 7th, 2012 at 4:52 am
Oh yes, I was so beyond the point of caring about decorum at that point! 😀 I think if I were to try these again I’d skip the bulk of the filling too – they’d definitely be easier to roll!
[Reply]
Glad you kept good spirits. I’m not sure if I would have been so forgiving, but then again, they were delicious!
[Reply]
Heather
March 7th, 2012 at 4:57 am
Hi Lauren! Yeah, the taste definitely made up for the issues I had!
[Reply]
Yeah, I had a similar looking baking sheet….they just didn’t want to stay rolled up 🙂 But so yummy…fun baking with you this week~
[Reply]
Heather
March 7th, 2012 at 5:05 am
Hi Liz! I agree, the taste definitely made up for the looks!
[Reply]
This was definitely a learning experience for me too. Glad you enjoyed your results.
[Reply]
Heather
March 7th, 2012 at 5:07 am
Hi Deena! I agree, it was a great learning experience!
[Reply]
Sorry they didn’t look good, but as long as they tasted good, right? It seems a lot of people had a hard time rolling!!
[Reply]
Heather
March 7th, 2012 at 5:13 am
Oh yes, the taste definitely made up for the issues!
[Reply]
you think that’s a lot of wasted filling, you should’ve seen my first attempt – more of my filling ended up on my work surface and the floor than in my rugelach!
[Reply]
Heather
March 7th, 2012 at 5:58 pm
I so believe it! I’m very impressed you gave it a second shot, I love the idea of these as a much simpler process.
[Reply]
I thought there was way too much filling as well. They are super tasty, though!
[Reply]
Heather
March 7th, 2012 at 5:59 pm
They really are, it definitely made up for how they looked!
[Reply]